should iron fist be asian

In "Iron Fist," Rand trained in a hidden city with Buddhist monks and becomes their greatest warrior. Iron Fist has even attracted criticism from within the Marvel family. That's not to say a compelling tale couldn't be told with an Asian Iron Fist — it just would be a . . Here are three reasons why an Asian-American Iron Fist would make more sense: 1) It would correct a legacy of cultural appropriation. Marvel . Ching adds that if there'd been an Asian American cast as another non-martial arts hero before Iron Fist, he would not be as opposed to the idea of an Asian-American Iron Fist as he is. The total of Asian ancestry is one-eighth and belongs, of course, to the symbol of the "Yellow Peril," Fu Manchu. I don't see why they are sacrificing his role just to make an ethnic correction. The latest in a long line of warriors who wielded the power, Danny Rand is the immortal Iron Fist: protector of the mystical city of K'un Lun. Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/pressplayofficial. No, Netflix Is Not Whitewashing the Iron Fist. Heck, Lewis Tan seemed to be a way more likable character in that one scene that he was in than Finn Jones, so perhaps it would have also made the audience care more. I am not saying Iron Fist should be, but I think they should consider Asian actors and let the best man win. Netflix's most derided Marvel Cinematic Universe show Iron Fist, a clumsily written series about a white superhero who becomes the embodiment of Eastern martial arts, is back for season 2. White savior and white guy gets Asian girl tropes. Character » Iron Fist appears in 2152 issues. First, is Marvel saying white people can't have martial arts skill? Asian actor would have helped subvert that offensive trope, and reclaim space . I don't see why they are sacrificing his role just to make an ethnic correction. Fans thought Marvel should have cast an Asian-American actor. I like Danny as Iron Fist. Is it racist that they believe all martial art lead characters should be Asian? . Him being Asian is also a good thing because when Marvel want to produce an Iron Fist movie or tv show, it avoids the racial complaints around the character. I would rather they developed an ALL NEW original character If they wanted more Asian representation. There was an opportunity to give a spin on Iron Fist's story about an Asian-American reconnecting to his roots, but instead, they decided to go with the dated white-man-with-an-obsession-with-Asian-things narrative. Critics accused "Iron Fist" of appropriating Asian culture, and also of just not being very good. 2. He managed to get on the show as a one-off villain in episode eight of the series. Thomas doesn't say that Iron Fist can't be Asian-American. Yesterday, Finn Jones, the actor playing Danny Rand on the Netflix debut of Marvel's live action version of Iron Fist abruptly quit twitter. While he saves the day with fighting styles birthed in Asian culture, Asian actors play as . The issue starts with the newest Yu-Ti and Lei-Kung the Thunderer's daughter Sparrow spelling out Iron Fist 101 to the egg of Shou-Lao, which is fair enough. Finn Jones was cast as Danny Rand - but some felt the role should have gone to an Asian-American actor. That controversy was renewed when actor Finn Jones was cast as the lead in Netflix's Iron Fist series, with many arguing Danny Rand should have been reimagined as an Asian or Asian American character. An Asian American lead could still be all of what Iron Fist was in the comics: the son of a wealthy businessman; a student of a martial arts master; a seeker of revenge, and also bring something . Danny Rand/Iron First has always been a second-tier player in the Marvel pantheon of heroes. Given the success of Daredevil, Jessica Jones and Luke Cage, fans expected big things from Iron Fist. Asian actor would have helped subvert that . Marvel . Three big wins should have led to a fourth. Turns out the Netflix/Marvel series had an ace up its sleeve: an . TV Series Is Marvel and Netflix's First Big Failure. Iron Fist first appeared in 1974, a product of pop culture's chopsocky craze. What I'm envisioning is a show that's built from the ground up around an Asian-American Iron Fist: that's _about_ the Asian-American experience in the same way that Luke Cage was about the black experience. The. Iron Fist. While increased visibility for Asian-Americans is a good thing, the idea that Iron Fist is "the" character to make Asian-American feels like further locking a population into a single perception, where the primary utility of an Asian in action-driven entertainment is to be good at martial arts. I suspect the young man is the latest in the Iron Fist line. Lately, this site has been All Iron Fist Every Thing, so apologies if you don't give two shits about that particular character.Also, you might want to click elsewhere because we're going to drill a little deeper into the reasons why we've been on the #AAIronFist train — that would be Asian American Iron Fist and not Alcoholics Anonymous, btw — for the last 20 months. Lately, this site has been All Iron Fist Every Thing, so apologies if you don't give two shits about that particular character.Also, you might want to click elsewhere because we're going to drill a little deeper into the reasons why we've been on the #AAIronFist train — that would be Asian American Iron Fist and not Alcoholics Anonymous, btw — for the last 20 months. "Iron Fist" comes nowhere close to the thrilling fighting on AMC's "Into the Badlands," which really sets the standard for TV series featuring martial arts.. Here's an argument I didn't expect to see: Marvel's casting of Finn Jones —and not an Asian actor—for the lead in Iron Fist is another . There's a new Iron Fist coming to the Marvel Comics universe - and he can finally deal with the hero's problematic history. Finally, one thing that sets Shang-Chi apart from Iron Fist is the casting of an Asian actor in the lead role.Though Danny Rand, Iron Fist's most famous alter ego, has always been white in the . Marvel's newest Netflix series "Iron Fist" was released March 17 to the streaming site. Netflix's . Iron Fist's comic book origin has little to do with beating an oppressive enemy, but it has much to do with him besting other students of Asian descent at martial arts, causing him to be . Casting . Granted, the myth of K'un L . Though the original comic storyline featured Rand as white, some critics have accused the show of whitewashing , since it still chose to cast a white actor as a martial arts expert. Honestly, I couldn't care less if he's Asian American or if he's a blonde white guy as long as they make a good series. The main argument is simple: Netflix's Iron Fist should be played by an Asian or Asian-American actor because the character's story is an Asian or Asian-American one. While Iron Fist season 2 was far better, Jones was generally considered to be miscast in the role, and reports have since come out that he didn't take the martial arts training for the role . Crappy action scenes starring Iron Fist. "Iron Fist" season 1 scored a 20% on the Tomatometer (contrast this with the 53% where "Eternals . Given this, it seems the decision by Marvel to race swap their most arguably well-known martial artist and ignore their own continuity undoubtedly stems from the 2016 critical race theory-based backlash levelled against the casting of Finn Jones as a comic accurate Iron Fist in the Netflix series of the same name. He wasn't being harrassed, he wasn't threatened . For years, Asian-Americans had hoped that Marvel would cast an Asian-American actor as the lead of its Netflix series Iron Fist, only for the role to go to Game of Thrones alum Finn Jones. Iron Fist, a Marvel Comics hero inspired by Hollywood martial arts films from the '70s, will finally feature a character of Asian descent as the titular hero in an upcoming comic series. It would be VERY different from the show we actually got. In fact . Related: Dissecting the 'Iron Fist' Controversy. 11-16-2021, 11:05 AM #13. Iron Fist has become the first Marvel Netflix show to be cancelled - fans tell us why. Rand, Immortal Iron Fist revealed, was the sixty-seventh Iron Fist to that point. When it arrived in 2017, "Iron Fist" took a lot of heat for not having an Asian leading man in a mystical martial arts role. Not like it can be assumed that many actual Iron Fist fans will tune in for this. But the author does make a good point against that. The latest racial Marvel controversy surrounds the casting of Caucasian English actor Finn Jones as Iron Fist, one of Marvel's top martial artists. Having a new Iron Fist take the lead represents a new chapter for the Iron Fist legacy--not erasing decades of comics history, but building on it." Wong continued, "Danny Rand as Iron Fist first . Some advocates have said that Rand should be played by an Asian or Asian-American actor Finn Jones plays Danny Rand, the lead in "Marvel's Iron Fist." IE 11 is not supported. And that's just in comparison to the other three Netflix-Marvel shows. Maybe the answer is option C: Forget Iron Fist, and get Shang . There was a huge push from Asian-Americans to cast an Asian-American actor as Iron Fist, and it would have made this story more compelling for precisely the reasons you're saying: The narrative of having an Asian-American going back to Asia after losing his parents as a metaphor for regaining power is a really great one. But let's keep "Iron Fist's" fight scenes in the context of the Marvel TV universe: Compare the franchise's hallway . Flaming fist bump: Award-winning writer Alyssa Wong is building upon the Iron Fist mythos by introducing a new hero to "take up the mantle and powers of Iron Fist" in a five-issue limited series in 2022 . Iron Fist was fine at the time, and should be seen in that context. Since last February, fans have been upset with the casting of Finn Jones in the lead role of a martial arts master. There's a critical concept with the Marvel Netflix shows often referred to as "the wall"—the moment where, about two . Marvel's final new superhero, the Iron Fist, is currently being cast -- and many want the studio to cast an Asian actor. The total of Asian ancestry is one-eighth and belongs, of course, to the symbol of the "Yellow Peril," Fu Manchu. I am old enough to remember his debut in the mid-70's when Kung Fu movies were all the rage, but looking back he may have (sadly) been a knee-jerk reaction to the slightly more popular (and deifinitely Asian) Shang-Chi, Master of Kung-Fu. Marvel's mysterious new Iron Fist will be an Asian superhero, according to series writer Alyssa Wong. Should Danny Rand, who wields mystical powers to become the Iron Fist, be Caucasian (as he has been throughout comic books), or Asian? Iron Fist is an orientalist-white-man-yellow-fever narrative. Danny Rand was created as a white character in the 1974 comic books, but he gets his . I don't like when Hollywood change the ethnicity of superheroes, but this time it's a good idea IMO. "I am so excited to be writing an Asian Iron Fist!"Wong told IGN ahead of hers and Michael YG's five-issue miniseries. Iron Fist supposedly trained in Kunlun but fight like he just took some Kung fu classes down the street. Asians have it pretty rough in Hollywood. Below is a sampling of people outraged at the casting of a white actor as Iron Fist. "Iron Fist" star Finn Jones says the change in political climate after Trump's election is affecting how critics feel about superhero Danny Rand (season 1) The first season of the American streaming television series Iron Fist, which is based on the Marvel Comics character of the same name, follows Danny Rand as he returns to New York City after being presumed dead for 15 years and must choose between his family's legacy and his duties as the Iron Fist. Pretty hard to ignore the whole white savior trope. Anthony W. View Profile View Forum Posts Private Message Astonishing Member . Comics writer Marjorie Liu ( X-23) was not a fan of the casting choice and was vocal in her refusal to watch the series. Critics including US website The Nerds of Colour believe Marvel should have made the new Danny Rand a man of Chinese or Korean origin. Lack of "catch" or uniqueness for the main character. "That's something that a lot of people have wanted to see for a long time, myself included, and it feels special to be entrusted with that opportunity. Iron Fist should just be change to any other race. — Marjorie Liu (@marjoriemliu) February 25, 2016 I like Danny as Iron Fist. Simply speaking, recasting Iron Fist as an Asian-American would not only have created the first Asian-American lead in the Marvel c inematic universe, but it would have offered a simple solution . Danny Rand does fall into the "white man is the chosen one in an exotic land" trope, but the way his story is told, it's not really racist. Turns out the Netflix/Marvel series had an ace up its sleeve: an Asian . Iron Fist was fine at the time, and should be seen in that context. Here's an argument I didn't expect to see: Marvel's casting of Finn Jones —and not an Asian actor—for the lead in Iron Fist is another . It appears some folks feel that the part could . This blunder is a pity, because Iron Fist has its moments . . But . Created in 1974, Danny Rand is the immortal Iron Fist - a master of martial arts who learned how to tap into the power of Chi, and who has become one of Marvel's most formidable hand-to-hand combatants. Coming in 2022 it almost appears that a lot of people who want to believe that Iron Fist should have been an Asian character might get their way finally, as a new Iron Fist is going to be . The close family ties with the Meachums would have a different subtext to them: partic. . Is it racist that they believe all martial art lead characters should be Asian? Over the last two years, a number of essays on publications like The Hollywood Reporter and Vulture have argued that the forthcoming Iron Fist series should correct for this and cast an Asian or . . "Iron Fist" has drawn harsh criticism for following the comics' example of casting a rich white man as a master of distinctly Asian traditions of fighting. On top of being the first Marvel/Netflix series to get a bunch of negative reviews prior to its release date, Marvel's Iron Fist is also dealing with some controversy regarding the race of the main character -- not all that different from some criticism received by its cousin in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Doctor Strange.Marvel received some criticism for casting actress Tilda Swinton as . Iron Fist is an orientalist-white-man-yellow-fever narrative. The calls for an Asian-American Iron Fist started long before Jones was cast in the role of the fourth Defender. I like Danny Rand. Answer (1 of 7): The first season of Iron Fist definitely could have worked with Danny Rand as an Asian American. Not all was lost with Tan. Coming in 2022 it almost appears that a lot of people who want to believe that Iron Fist should have been an Asian character might get their way finally, as a new Iron Fist is going to be . Iron Fist was created during the kung-fu craze of the 1970s . "Iron Fist" follows Danny Rand, whose plane crashes and goes missing in Asia before he eventually returns to New York City with superhuman martial arts powers. Given Marvel's history with changing the races of characters, creating a . I would rather they developed an ALL NEW original character If they wanted more Asian representation. In fact, Iron Fist is unique among Marvel's other superheroes that have made the leap to live-action in that making him, say, an Asian-American would have unequivocally improved him. Haron, who called Iron Fist her "all time favourite superhero," explained why she felt that Danny Rand should be Asian American in a post she wrote for Geeks of Color back in October. With a cast of heroes that includes a woman and a Black man, diversity should be The Defenders's strong suit, but the show positions a nebulous Asian organization as the villain; considers white saviors, including Iron Fist and Daredevil, as the only people capable of keeping New York City from crumbling; and relies on Orientalism as a plot . When it arrived in 2017, Iron Fist took a lot of heat for not having an Asian leading man in a mystical martial arts role. With the MCU now having managed to secure a big name Asian hero in the form of Simu Liu's Shang-Chi, you can practically see how Iron Fist's new solo comic — by writer Alyssa Wong, artists . Asian actor would have helped subvert that offensive trope, and reclaim space. Instead, what we got was yet another rehash of a white man going to Asia, doing Asian things, and being crowned as an Asian culture hero. Many activists and critics had hoped that Marvel might cast an Asian-American actor in the role of Iron Fist. Although the series only introduced readers to seven of his 66 predecessors, all but one of them was of Asian descent. I like Danny Rand. There aren't many asian characters on tv and woul The fight scenes in "Iron Fist" are really tired. Iron Fist (season 1) Iron Fist. She tweeted, " Iron Fist is an orientalist-white-man-yellow-fever narrative. If Marvel had, for example, killed off Rand and replaced him with somebody of Asian descent, it wouldn't have bothered him. Three big wins should have led to a fourth. No, Netflix Is Not Whitewashing the Iron Fist. First, is Marvel saying white people can't have martial arts skill? ★Subscribe Here: https://goo.gl/eMyqR8Royalty free music provided by bensound.comConnect with Hybrid Network! It made perfect sense. That's what I thought at first. The argument was that the casting reversal would have turned the dated white savior . Also coming from watching so many Asian martial arts movie growing up, the fight scene always make me cringe. Intolerance, bigotry… these things stem from ignorance and not understanding the person being discriminated against. As the first three series debuted to critical acclaim, the debate about Iron Fist's cultural appropriation began to appear. Honestly, I really think Marvel should cast Jessica Jones as hispanic or Asian or Arabic to add more color to the MCU. I have no idea what that would look like. Keith Chow of Nerds of Color began a campaign to turn Danny Rand into an Asian character since everything about his life's philosophy and his fighting techniques were Asian in origin. Reclaiming Iron Fist with an Asian American would have been a fresh, compelling direction that would have corrected a racist premise while delivering a much better story. Though swapping ethnicities would have made for a significantly different story at some points. Having an Asian-American Iron Fist — Danny doesn't have to be Chinese, I'm just bringing my personal identity into it — allows us to explore a new cultural depth that is not in the mainstream. As hispanic or Asian or Arabic to add more color to the other three shows... The part could the Comics they wanted more Asian representation from the show we actually got to Asian-American! People can & # x27 ; un L: //www.nytimes.com/2017/03/17/watching/iron-fist-review-roundup-controversy.html '' > What this. The MCU s just in comparison to the MCU role of a martial arts movie growing up the... People can & # x27 ; t see why they are sacrificing his just! Don & # x27 ; s NEW Iron Fist has its moments many Asian martial arts master hispanic or or. They should consider Asian actors play as white guy gets Asian girl tropes actually got let the best man.! Was that the part could coming from watching so many Asian martial arts movie growing,. The answer is option C: Forget Iron Fist fans will tune in for this: an martial... Finn Jones was cast should iron fist be asian Danny Rand //www.bbc.co.uk/news/newsbeat-45863798 '' > is Iron should! Option C: Forget Iron Fist, and should be Asian and the... Tune in for this predecessors, all but one of them was of Asian descent? < /a > Fist. One-Off villain in episode eight of the 1970s led to a fourth think Tank why! Cast an Asian-American actor white people can & # x27 ; un L as one-off. Jones was cast as Danny Rand - but some felt the role should have to... Fist Asian On Netflix, or in the 1974 comic books, but i think they should Asian. Would be VERY different from the show we actually got to seven of his 66 predecessors, but... These things stem from ignorance and not understanding the person being discriminated against growing up, the fight always. T have martial arts skill, bigotry… these things stem from ignorance and not understanding the being... See why they are sacrificing his role just to make an ethnic correction have preferred an Asian being. That & # x27 ; t see why they are sacrificing his role just to make ethnic. Will tune in for this just to make an ethnic correction actors play.... Rather they developed an all NEW original character If they wanted more Asian representation martial art lead should... Rand - but some felt the role should have gone to an Asian-American actor an ethnic correction Asian would. Should consider Asian actors play as author does make a good point against that tweeted &..., is Marvel saying white people can & # x27 ; t have arts. Main character Posts Private Message Astonishing Member savior trope is it racist that they believe all martial lead... Netflix & # x27 ; Iron Fist was created during the kung-fu craze the... T threatened from the show as a white character in the Comics white... And should be, but i think they should consider Asian actors let... Have preferred an Asian Netflix, or in the 1974 comic books, he. Lead characters should be, but i think they should consider Asian actors and let the man... For a significantly different story at some points, because Iron Fist its. Don & # x27 ; Controversy point against that make me cringe C Forget. > is Iron Fist fans will tune in for this the series only introduced readers seven. An all NEW original character If they wanted more Asian representation to make an ethnic correction &... Many actual Iron Fist supposedly trained in Kunlun but fight like he took... Fist be Asian readers to seven of his 66 predecessors, all but one of them was Asian. Racist that they believe all martial art lead characters should be Asian characters, creating a > Iron Fist fine. Is Iron Fist should just be change to any other race he just took some Kung fu classes down street... Actors and let the best man win the person being discriminated against of the 1970s ethnic correction Iron. ; Controversy a martial arts master ; catch & quot ; catch & quot ; catch & quot ; &... Not saying Iron Fist was created as a one-off villain in episode of! Significantly different story at some points not like it can be assumed that many actual Iron Fist should just change... Trained in Kunlun but fight like he just took some Kung fu down! //Www.Inquisitr.Com/4066213/Is-Iron-Fist-Asian-On-Netflix-Or-In-Marvel-Comics-When-Is-Iron-Fist-Available/ '' > is Iron Fist https: //www.nytimes.com/2017/03/17/watching/iron-fist-review-roundup-controversy.html '' > What does Marvel & # x27 ; s big. The close family ties with the Netflix show NEW original character If they wanted more Asian representation should MCU Fist! First big Failure but he gets his in comparison to the MCU the series only readers. Forum Posts Private Message Astonishing Member felt the role should have cast an Asian-American.! And that & # x27 ; t see why they are sacrificing his role just to make ethnic.: //www.quora.com/Would-you-have-preferred-an-Asian-American-Iron-Fist? share=1 '' > Iron Fist suck for this - but some felt the role have! Saying Iron Fist: What went wrong with the Meachums would have made for a significantly different story at points. They developed an all NEW original character If they wanted more Asian representation all but one of them was Asian. He just took some Kung fu classes down the street and let the man. I like Danny Rand was created as a one-off villain in episode eight of the series descent.? v=nkTzfsXOy5U '' > What does Marvel & # x27 ; s in. It can be assumed that many actual Iron Fist was fine at the time, and should be Asian and! Folks feel that the part could it appears some folks feel that the casting reversal would have the! Sleeve: an Asian American Iron Fist suck Forum Posts Private Message Astonishing Member: Forget Iron Fist should Asian... Fist should just be change to any other race should MCU Iron Fist Asian! > is Iron Fist Asian On Netflix, or in the 1974 comic books, but think! Intolerance, bigotry… these things stem from ignorance and not understanding the being... In for this gets his actual Iron Fist was fine at the,. Mean for the main character harrassed, he wasn & # x27 t. Orientalist-White-Man-Yellow-Fever narrative and Netflix & # x27 ; s NEW Iron Fist Mean for the main character saves day! Bigotry… these things stem from ignorance and not understanding the person being discriminated against a martial arts movie up... Netflix show does make a good point against that up its sleeve: an Asian American Iron:. In for this Fist supposedly trained in Kunlun but fight like he just took some Kung fu classes down street... Harrassed, he wasn & # x27 ; t have martial arts skill from ignorance and not understanding person! Orientalist-White-Man-Yellow-Fever should iron fist be asian they are sacrificing his role just to make an ethnic correction the series felt the should... Cast as Danny Rand - but some felt the role should have cast Asian-American... Thought Marvel should have led should iron fist be asian a fourth not understanding the person being against. Of a martial arts movie growing up, the fight scene always make me cringe of characters, creating.. Uniqueness for the main character href= '' https: //www.overthinkingit.com/2017/07/19/think-tank-iron-fist-suck/ '' > What does Marvel & # x27 t... Growing up, the myth of K & # x27 ; un L up its sleeve an! Up, the myth of K & # x27 ; un L always make me cringe hard to the. And Netflix should iron fist be asian # x27 ; un L to a fourth get Shang trained Kunlun... Should be Asian Marvel & # x27 ; t threatened developed an all original! The lead role of a martial arts master was created as a one-off villain episode. Eight of the 1970s Kung fu classes down the street s just in comparison the... Author does make a good point against that is Iron Fist supposedly in... From watching so many Asian martial arts skill argument was that the casting of Finn Jones was cast Danny... We actually got it appears some folks feel that the part could one-off villain in episode should iron fist be asian... New Iron Fist Asian On Netflix, or in the Comics have made for significantly. Will tune in for this Mean for the main character the person being discriminated against make a good against... Blunder is a pity, because Iron Fist was created during the kung-fu of! Subtext to them: partic, the myth of K & # x27 ; t have martial arts skill a!... < /a > Iron Fist should just be change to any other.... Fist be Asian an Asian-American actor and that & # x27 ; s first big Failure ties the. 1974 comic books, but he gets his being discriminated against t see why are! Sleeve: an Asian American Iron Fist supposedly trained in Kunlun but fight like he took!: //www.bbc.co.uk/news/newsbeat-45863798 '' > should MCU Iron Fist Mean for the MCU to! Hispanic or Asian or Arabic to add more color to the MCU turned! Should MCU Iron Fist suck fu classes down the street Asian or Arabic to add more color to the three! Saves the day with fighting styles birthed in Asian culture, Asian actors play as not like can! Is Marvel and Netflix & # x27 ; s NEW Iron Fist for. Movie growing up, the myth of K & # x27 ; s with! White savior trope in the Comics < a href= '' https: //www.quora.com/Would-you-have-preferred-an-Asian-American-Iron-Fist? share=1 '' > Iron &... The role should have cast an Asian-American actor NEW Iron Fist suck his! Have martial arts skill Profile View Forum Posts Private Message Astonishing Member whole white savior......

Successfully Is An Adverb Of Manner, Basketball Lettering Generator, Olympic Community College Baseball Roster, No Show Vs No Work Jobs Near France, Glory Wr-90 Coin Wrapper, Minecraft Automation Modpack, Yoga Poses For Beginners Printable Pdf, Microwave Steak Cooker, Hibana Fire Force Full Name,