animal testing should be banned debate points
Accordingly, potential animal rights violations are outweighed by the greater human benefits of animal research. Animal testing should not be banned completely. In the absence of better alternatives, it helps us acquire knowledge about the effects of drugs. But, yes, the testing should be carried out carefully so that it does not result in the death of the animals. Rangan Banik, Class XI, Aditya Academy Secondary, Calcutta The Debate on Animal Experimentation Sather Health Many medical research institutions make use of non-human animals as test subjects. The idea is that mammals, such as apes, horses and rats, will have similar reactions to humans. Its wrong and should be banned. 832.813.6500, document.write(new Date().getFullYear()); Lone Star College, LSC-North Harris English Faculty Resources, LSC-North Harris English Faculty and Staff, Jeffrey and Lonette Stayton Awards for Writing, Campus Health, Safety, and Risk-Management Awareness (CHSRMA), Drug and Alcohol Abuse Prevention Program (DAAPP), State Auditor's Office Fraud, Waste or Abuse Hotline, Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board (THECB). Urology drugs have the lowest success rate (only 4% are approved after entering clinical trials) followed by heart drugs (5% success rate), cancer drugs (5% success rate) and neurology drugs (6% success rate). Understanding both sides of the debate about animal testing is crucial Yet, for every reason to test on animals, there are multiple counterarguments for why we shouldnt. Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine, source@https://animalethics101.blogspot.com/p/nathan-nobis.html, status page at https://status.libretexts.org. Eyewitness Expos: Pain, Fear, and Death at Primate Products, Inc. PLRS: Undercover at a Product-Testing Laboratory, Psychological Torture Experiments at NIH Must Stop, The Silver Spring Monkeys: The Case That Launched PETA, The University of Utah Must Stop Its Rogue Animal Experimenters, Victory! Animals and Their Medical Use., Regan, Tom. Two of the most commonly used toxicity tests are the Draize test and the LD50 test, both of which are infamous for the intense pain and suffering they inflect upon experimental animals. The use of animals in research is never undertaken lightly. When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments. WebAnimal Testing Debate 3,729 views Feb 25, 2020 Middle school students debate whether or not animal testing should be eliminated. Its not only dangerous, cruel, painful, and inhumane; some of the methods harken back to medieval torture chambers. Research shows that these choices could explain the variability in age of onset and progression of disease observed in HD patients. This page titled 8.10: Animal Testing Should Be Banned is shared under a CC BY-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Nathan Nobis (Open Philosophy Press) via source content that was edited to the style and standards of the LibreTexts platform; a detailed edit history is available upon request. Below, I will outline one of the more common arguments used to reach this conclusion. But suppose someone wanted to rob a bank and needed a getaway car: there is no alternative to a car and so it is necessary for the robbery. Many animal rights advocates argue similarlythat just because we are human is not sufficient grounds to declare animals less morally significant. Do your students need to conduct an interview as part of their research? The value that humans place on their own lives should be extended to the lives of animals as well. WebConducting research on animals has led to significant breakthroughs in the worlds of science and medicine, and it must not be banned since its benefits outweigh its costs. This includes taking medicine or relying on treatments that have been developed through testing. Animal Testing Should Be Animal testing in the United States is regulated by the federal Animal Welfare Act (AWA), passed in 1966 and amended in 1970, 1976, and 1985.The AWA People have different feelings for animals; many look upon animals as companions while others view animals as a means for advancing medical techniques or furthering experimental research. Here are just a few of the myriad reasons why many people believe its time to end this practice. Argumentative Essay: Should Animal Testing Be Banned Millions of animals are used and killed in the name of progress every year. Text UGLY to 73822 to tell UGGs to choose vegan materials and stop supporting the mutilation and violent killing of sheep! Stay up to date on the latest vegan trends and get breaking animal rights news delivered straight to your inbox! Because there are other alternatives that would replace or relieve animal testing, the use of animals would decrease dramatically. Therefore, animals should not be used in research or to test the safety of products. To correct these misconceptions, members of the HOPES team will be going through various depictions of HD in the media to determine what aspects of HD are presented properly and what aspects are misrepresented. Urge Texas A&M to Stop Funding Cruel Experiments on Dogs. WebDebate about whether or not tests on animals should be banned. The rules surrounding animal testing vary from country to country. Animal testing should be banned because it is an unethical process. If animals do not have the same rights as humans, it becomes permissible to use them for research purposes. WebThe answer of course is NO. Experimental animals are virtually tortured to death, and all of these tests are done in the interest of human welfare, without any thought to how the animals are treated. Although humans often benefit from successful animal research, the pain, the suffering, and the deaths of animals are not worth the possible human benefits. However, many people believe that animal testing is justified because the animals are sacrificed to make products safer for human use and consumption. In the UK, all medicines including vaccinations must be tested on animals before they are licensed for human use. Most people without a scientific education or lots of experience with animal behavior, domestic, farm or wildlife, dont understand the HUGE role instinct has on animals. The support for animal testing is based largely on anecdote and is not backed up, we believe, by the scientific evidence that is out there. Animal Testing Should Be Banned - An Empath's Approach Current subscribers: You will continue to receive e-mail unless you explicitly opt out by clicking, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. Our new HOPES podcast aims at sharing stories and voices of caretakers, doctors, and those impacted by Huntingtons Disease. Their decisions are made for them because they cannot vocalize their own preferences and choices. This reflects a belief in a hierarchy of moral standing with more complex animals at the top and microorganisms and plants at the bottom. It is universally acknowledged that animals play an indispensable role in scientific research. in Orlans 26). 7 Reasons Why Animal Experimentation Is Just The Body Shop, 1993. Animals living with the induced conditions is unpleasant also. The HOPES team aims to make our Huntington's Disease (HD) information and resources accessible to people of all HD backgrounds and experiences. Theshow more content. Making use of alternatives that are available for animal experimentation is therefore, a better choice. Human volunteers testing a new monoclonal antibody treatment (TGN1412) at Northwick Park Hospital, UK, in 2006 suffered a severe immune reaction and nearly died. For example bacteria, fruit flies, and plants would be preferred over mammals. After all, when it comes to animal testing, there are clearly more cons than pros. Why Should Animal Testing Be Banned? Vegomm Msg/data rates may apply. After all, humans are animals too. WebIn a huge victory for animals, the European Union (EU), Israel, and India have banned the sale of any cosmetics or cosmetics ingredients that have been tested on animals. In his article entitled "Time to Reform Toxic Tests," Michael Balls, a professor of medial cell biology at the University of Nottingham and chairman of the trustees of FRAME (the Fund for the Replacement of Animals in Medical Experiments), states that the LD50 test is "scientifically unjustifiable. 3. Why Animal Testing Should Not Be Banned | ipl.org Fill out the form at the bottom of our Request a Speaker page and well be in touch about scheduling a virtual presentation to your class from Dr. Katherine Roe, the chief of the Science Advancement & Outreach division at PETA. subtitle: Working to create a world where no animals suffer in a laboratory, Animal experiments are cruel, unreliable, and even dangerous. Finally, the testing of products on animals is completely unnecessary because viable alternatives are available. We have cured mice of cancer for decades and it simply didnt work in human beings. "Animals in zoos suffer tremendously, both physically and mentally. Support your stance with a logical argument. The history of cancer research has been the history of curing cancer in the mouse. Is Animal Testing Ever Justified? - The New York Times WebWhat are some reminders during debate. Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life. Animals do not willingly sacrifice themselves for the advancement of human welfare and new technology. In the past decade, intensive research efforts have given scientists a much better understanding of how HD damages the brain. Therefore, it is ethically wrong to use harmful and invasive research on such animals. If these atrocious acts were committed outside laboratories, they would be felonies. Our research and points of view will help you answer the question: why should animal testing be banned? Do they lack fundamental human rights and should we use them for experimentation? Research Animal Resources. Animal Testing Should Be Banned In India, there are case reports from Punjab and northern India and until 1990, there were 69 case reports of HD in China. However, in Asia, the prevalence of HD is approximately one tenth of the HD prevalence in Western population. The very first reason why animal testing should be banned is elementary: it is cruel and unnecessary. With that in mind, the argument runs, it is best practice to act charitably and treat all humans as part of the moral community.
Should animal testing be banned? According to data collected by F. Barbara Orlans for her book, In the Name of Science: Issues in Responsible Animal Experimentation, sixty percent of all animals used in testing are used in biomedical research and product-safety testing (62). Animal Testing Should Be Its wasteful. Others respond that animals themselves benefit from animal research. Msg/data rates may apply. This involves detailed examination of the procedures and the number and type of animals used. Why? The LibreTexts libraries arePowered by NICE CXone Expertand are supported by the Department of Education Open Textbook Pilot Project, the UC Davis Office of the Provost, the UC Davis Library, the California State University Affordable Learning Solutions Program, and Merlot. They do not represent every possible argument, or even necessarily the best arguments. Yet, such experiments belittle the complexity of human conditions which are affected by wide-ranging variables such as genetics, socio-economic factors, deeply-rooted psychological issues and different personal experiences. Animals are also regularly tested by the military. It is immoral for live humans to be used for possibly dangerous science experiments. Instead, signs of these diseases are artificially induced in animals in laboratories in an attempt to mimic the human disease. Another way to reduce animal use is to ensure that studies are conducted according to the highest standards and that all information collected will be useable. The UK government has admitted to testing on animals to develop protective pharmaceuticals, such as Nerve Agent Pretreatment Sets (NAPS), but this is just one example of how animals are used in the armed forces. Web should poetry be made compulsory for children is agriculture still a relevant subject in schools why animals should not be held captive what is your perspective on. Extensive literature searches, for instance, can ensure that experiments are not unnecessarily replicated and can ensure that animal models are only used to obtain information not already available in the scientific community. Should Animal Testing Be Banned? - Riley Lawrence - Google Books Vioxx, a drug used to treat arthritis, was found to be safe when tested in monkeys (and five other animal species) but has been estimated to have caused around 140,000 heart attacks and strokes and 60,000 deaths worldwide. WebAnimal testing should be banned because it is cruel, unnecessary, inaccurate, and expensive. And more importantly, if my child were dying and I tried to experiment on my neighbors children to try to save my own child, that would be wrong. The Moral Community., Frey, R.G. According to Orlans, the animals suffer from "vomiting, diarrhea, paralysis, convulsion, and internal bleeding. subtitle: Animal testing is carried out in a wide range of areas, including biological research, and testing medicines and chemicals. In another method, in vitro testing, cellular tests are done inside a test tube. Accessibility StatementFor more information contact us atinfo@libretexts.orgor check out our status page at https://status.libretexts.org. But when one group benefits at the major expense of another group, thats usually wrong. The final reason why animal testing should be forbidden is that the rights of animals are continually violated. However, if we step into the shoes of the industries and businesses that do believe in animal testing, heres what we might argue. More recently, we. Some people advocate a European origin for the mutation, suggesting that migration and inter-racial mixture of genes led to a lower prevalence in non-European countries. Below, we look at these more closely. While a combination of chemical and human cell tests has been shown to accurately predict human skin reactions 90% of the time, skin irritation tests on rabbits only predict human reactions 60% of the time. Whats worse, scientific research isnt the only reason for animal testing. Animal testing involves experimenting on animals to try to determine whether drugs and medical treatments are safe and effective for humans. Are hot cheetos vegan? Here, we take an in-depth look at animal testing, how it affects animals across the world, and whether there are any circumstances where it should be accepted. References to HD in popular culture include, but are not limited to, books (as evidenced by our sites Literature Corner), television shows, films, radio programs, and newspaper articles. Animals may be subject to experimentation or modified into conditions useful for gaining knowledge about human disease or for testing potential human treatments. WebDue to this, animal testing has become an extreme controversial topic that has created a division among different groups, of those who are supporting the process and those who are opposing. On Sept. 10, the Environmental Protection Agency said it would move away from requiring the testing of potentially harmful chemicals on animals, a decision that subtitle: Millions of animals are used and killed in the name of progress every year. However, most people are uncomfortable with that scenario and some philosophers have put forth a variety of reasons to include all humans in the human moral community. This section includes a synopsis of the medias depiction of HD as well as a discussion of whether it was realistic and medically accurate. Everyone in the United States should be forced to vote. Animals should be treated with respect and dignity, and this right to decent treatment is not upheld when animals are exploited for selfish human gain. Because of the immense importance of nutrition, HOPES has developed this chapter to discuss some of the various foods and eating practices that can have both a general health-promoting effect, and also special benefits for people coping with Huntingtons disease. Animal experiments prolong the suffering of humans waiting for effective cures because the results mislead experimenters and squander precious money, time, and other resources that could be spent on human-relevant research. "Zoos are prisons for animals, camouflaging their cruelty with conservation claims," Mimi Bekhechi, director of international programmes at PETA, explains. English, 28.10.2019 18:29, joyce5512. To put it simply, animal testing is where products or solutions are tested on animals.